home
Skip to content
  • About us
    • About us
    • Aims and accountability
    • Who we are
    • Meetings
    • Committees
    • Recruitment
    • FAQ
  • Sentencing information
    • Sentencing information
    • Introduction to sentencing
    • How do courts decide a sentence?
    • Community sentences
    • Custodial sentences
    • Maximum and minimum sentences
    • Disposals and appeals
    • Information for victims
  • Sentencing guidelines
    • Sentencing guidelines
    • Approved guidelines
    • Guidelines in development
    • How are sentencing guidelines developed?
    • About sentencing guidelines
  • Publications
    • Publications
    • Guideline judgments
    • Sentencing Statements
  • Research and engagement
    • Research and engagement
    • Consultations
    • Research
    • Engagement
  • Education resources
    • Education resources
    • Jargon buster
    • Myth buster
    • 'If you were the judge' case studies
    • Lectures and lesson plans
  • News and media
    • News and media
    • News
    • Scottish Sentencing Conversations Podcast
    • Spotlight on Sentencing Blog
    • Spotlight on Sentencing Circular
    • Videos
    • Contact us
  • ?
  • A-Z
Scottish Sentencing Council Logo
  1. Home
  2. Publications
  3. Guideline judgments
  4. Appeals Against Sentence - Solemn

Appeals Against Sentence - Solemn

The opinions listed on this page have been made under section 118(7) of the Criminal Procedure (Scotland) Act 1995. 

Each link below will take you to an introductory summary of the listed case. From there, you can access a further link to the complete opinion for a fuller understanding of the case.  

Spence v HM Advocate

Case Details:

2007HCJAC62

09/11/2007

Appeal Court, High Court of Justiciary

Relevance:

This discusses whether it is ever appropriate to discount a sentence in a situation where an accused’s offer to plead guilty to a lesser offence has not been accepted by the Crown, but where the accused is ultimately convicted of that less serious offence. 

Du Plooy v HM Advocate

Case Details:

12005JC1

03/10/2003

Appeal Court, High Court of Justiciary

Relevance:

This gives guidance on the appropriate level of sentence discounts in cases where the accused has pled guilty.

Lin v HM Advocate

Case Details:

2007HCJAC62

02/11/2007

High Court of Justiciary

Relevance:

This addresses sentencing levels for those involved in a minor way with large scale drug operations.

HM Advocate v Boyle and others

Case Details:

2009HCJAC89

26/11/2009

High Court of Justiciary

Relevance:

This deals with the punishment parts of sentences in murder cases.

HM Advocate v Graham

Case Details:

2011J.C.1

27/05/2010

High Court of Justiciary

Relevance:

This considers offences relating to indecent images of children.  

Contact us/ media enquiries

 

Social media policy

 

Scottish Sentencing Council, Parliament House, Edinburgh, EH1 1RQ

Tel: 0300 790 0006 Email: sentencingcouncil@scotcourts.gov.uk
Follow us on social:
  • Accessibility
  • Complaints
  • Cookies
  • © Crown Copyright
  • FAQs
  • Jargon Buster
  • Privacy
  • Site Map
  • Useful links