home
Skip to content
  • About us
    • About us
    • Aims and accountability
    • Who we are
    • Meetings
    • Committees
    • Recruitment
    • FAQ
  • Sentencing information
    • Sentencing information
    • Introduction to sentencing
    • How do courts decide a sentence?
    • Community sentences
    • Custodial sentences
    • Maximum and minimum sentences
    • Disposals and appeals
    • Information for victims
  • Sentencing guidelines
    • Sentencing guidelines
    • Approved guidelines
    • Guidelines in development
    • How are sentencing guidelines developed?
    • About sentencing guidelines
  • Publications
    • Publications
    • Guideline judgments
    • Sentencing Statements
  • Research and engagement
    • Research and engagement
    • Consultations
    • Research
    • Engagement
  • Education resources
    • Education resources
    • Jargon buster
    • Myth buster
    • 'If you were the judge' case studies
    • Lectures and lesson plans
  • News and media
    • News and media
    • News
    • Scottish Sentencing Conversations Podcast
    • Spotlight on Sentencing Blog
    • Spotlight on Sentencing Circular
    • Videos
    • Contact us
  • ?
  • A-Z
Scottish Sentencing Council Logo
  1. Home
  2. Publications
  3. Guideline judgments
  4. Other Useful Judgments

Other Useful Judgments

The judgments listed on this page were not issued under the 1995 Act, but provide guidance on certain areas of sentencing.

Kelly v HM Advocate / Robertson v HM Advocate

Case Details:

Kelly (2001JC12), Robertson (2004JC155)

N/A

N/A

Relevance:

These cases deal with discretionary life sentences for sex offenders.

Kelly v HM Advocate (26 November 2000)

Robertson v HM Advocate (17 February 2004)

Petch & Foye v HM Advocate

Case Details:

2011HCJAC20

01/03/2011

High Court of Justiciary

Relevance:

This addresses the calculation of the punishment part of discretionary life sentences. 

Gemmell v HM Advocate

Case Details:

2011HCJAC129

20/12/2011

High Court of Justiciary

Relevance:

This judgment provides further guidance on sentencing discounts. 

HM Advocate v Noche

Case Details:

2011HCJAC108

28/10/2011

High Court of Justiciary

Relevance:

This judgment deals with death by driving – whether it is appropriate to have regard to a guideline from the Sentencing Council for England and Wales and what is in that guideline.

Milligan v HM Advocate

Case Details:

2015HCJAC84

08/09/2015

High Court of Justiciary

Relevance:

This judgment considers the use of sentencing guidelines from England and Wales in Scottish courts. 

Scottish Sea Farms Ltd v HM Advocate

Case Details:

2012HCJAC11

26/01/2012

High Court of Justiciary

Relevance:

This judgment sets out the principles to be used when sentencing health and safety cases. 

HM Advocate v Munro & Sons (Highland) Ltd

Case Details:

2009HCJAC10

28/01/2009

High Court of Justiciary

Relevance:

This judgment sets out the principles to be used when sentencing health and safety cases. 

Contact us/ media enquiries

 

Social media policy

 

Scottish Sentencing Council, Parliament House, Edinburgh, EH1 1RQ

Tel: 0300 790 0006 Email: sentencingcouncil@scotcourts.gov.uk
Follow us on social:
  • Accessibility
  • Complaints
  • Cookies
  • © Crown Copyright
  • FAQs
  • Jargon Buster
  • Privacy
  • Site Map
  • Useful links